Sunday, July 6, 2025
No Result
View All Result
News Report  Zimbabwe
  • News that Matters
    • News
    • Health and Diseases
    • Technology
    • Religion
    • Horror and Disaster
    • Elections 2023
  • Crime and Courts
  • Celebrity
  • Sports
  • Mjolo
  • Breaking News
  • News that Matters
    • News
    • Health and Diseases
    • Technology
    • Religion
    • Horror and Disaster
    • Elections 2023
  • Crime and Courts
  • Celebrity
  • Sports
  • Mjolo
  • Breaking News
No Result
View All Result
News Report  Zimbabwe
No Result
View All Result
Home Crime and Courts

State to appeal over Mamombe, Chimbiri acquittal

July 6, 2023
0
State to appeal over Mamombe, Chimbiri acquittal

The National Prosecuting Authority will appeal to the Supreme Court the acquittal of CCC officials Joana Mamombe and Cecilia Chimbiri by the High Court in the middle of their criminal trial in a lower court on charges of faking an abduction.

The two were on trial before Chief Magistrate Faith Mushure on charges of fabricating their abduction by State security agents in 2020 and publishing falsehoods.

They applied to be dxischarged at the end of the State case but the chief magistrate ruled that a case had been made against them and so they had to present their defence.

The two then appealed against that decision at the High Court, and Justice Priscilla Munangati-Manongwa upheld the application by the two for review of the magistrate’s decision, saying the lower court erred in declining the application for a finding that the State had not made a case against them.

The judge ruled that State witnesses’ testimony was conflicting, that the falsity of the alleged statement by the two accused was simply absent, and that the incriminating evidence against the two suspects had been discredited during cross-examination.

The judge then ruled such evidence had become so manifestly unreliable such that no reasonable court could safely convict on such evidence.

But the National Prosecuting Authority argues that the ruling is defective at law, and now seeks to appeal at the Supreme Court.

The NPA argues that two judges need to sit for a review or appeal to the High Court, and that the conditions for interfering with a trial that is in progress were not met, and so the appeal by the two accused should have been at the conclusion of the trial if they were found guilty.

“The State will be appealing the decision of the High Court in the case of Joana Mamombe and Cecelia Revei Chimbiri versus the Chief Magistrate F Mushure and the State,” said the NPA in a statement.

“The State is of the considered view that the judgment is defective for want of compliance with the High Court Act as well as a precedent, which provides that another judge must concur with the presiding Judge before the judgment is handed down.
“The State is also contending that the judge grossly misdirected herself by interfering with the unterminated proceedings from the lower court, as the termination of proceedings, in this case, was unjustified.”

To this end, the NPA strongly feels that another court presented with the same facts might come to a different conclusion.

Charges against Mamombe and Chimbiri arose when they allegedly claimed to have been seized by suspected state agents and taken to a secluded location outside of Harare.

While there, the two were allegedly understood to have claimed to have been subjected to torture and sexual assault, although they later in their trial denied making any such claim of abduction or ill treatment.

Upon their arrest, they were charged with communicating falsehoods. However, while in the middle of the trial, the High Court found them not guilty and acquitted them of all the charges.

Related Posts

Fake Receipt Fiasco: Two Men Busted for Ridiculous Scam

The Great Njube Heist: A Tale of Condoms, Cigarettes, and Bread

by Nyathi
July 5, 2025
0

In a shocking turn of events, a 32-year-old man from Njube, Ishmael Ndlovu, was sentenced to five months in prison...

Zimbabwean Journalist Arrested Over SADC Commentary

Zimbabwean Journalist Faith Zaba Released on Bail After Power Outage Delays Hearing

by Nyathi
July 5, 2025
0

Faith Zaba, editor of the Zimbabwe Independent, was granted bail on Friday after a power outage interrupted her bail hearing...

Harare Man Arrested for Attempting to Sell Human Fetus as Beef

Harare Man Arrested for Attempting to Sell Human Fetus as Beef

by Nyathi
July 5, 2025
0

A 19-year-old man in Harare, Zimbabwe, has been arrested for allegedly attempting to sell a human fetus as beef to...

Family Feud Turns Deadly: Grandson Accused of Killing 89-Year-Old Grandmother

Family Feud Turns Deadly: Grandson Accused of Killing 89-Year-Old Grandmother

by Nyathi
July 4, 2025
0

A tragic incident has shaken the community of Village 8B Square in Igusi, Nyamandlovu, after a 35-year-old man allegedly stoned...

Zimbabwe’s CVR Rocked by Sophisticated Scam: A Warning to All

Zimbabwe’s CVR Rocked by Sophisticated Scam: A Warning to All

by Nyathi
July 4, 2025
0

A cunning scam has hit Zimbabwe's Central Vehicle Registry (CVR) , targeting newly licensed drivers with fake messages demanding US$50...

Cop’s Car Conundrum: A Tale of Mistaken Identity

Cop’s Car Conundrum: A Tale of Mistaken Identity

by Nyathi
July 4, 2025
0

In a bizarre turn of events, a Bulawayo traffic cop found himself at the center of a car smuggling scandal,...

Please login to join discussion

Trending News Today

  • Teacher Takes Own Life at Kwite Primary School

    Teacher Takes Own Life at Kwite Primary School

    85 shares
    Share 34 Tweet 21
  • Mai Titi’s Latest Drama: Arrest and US$100K Suit Threatened

    61 shares
    Share 24 Tweet 15
  • The Unspoken Struggles of Zimbabweans Abroad

    54 shares
    Share 22 Tweet 14
  • $4 Million Ecobank Heist: Security Guard Arrested in Major Breakthrough

    182 shares
    Share 73 Tweet 46
  • Harare Man Arrested for Attempting to Sell Human Fetus as Beef

    43 shares
    Share 17 Tweet 11
  • The Natural Order of Things: A Man’s Role in Providing for His Family

    35 shares
    Share 14 Tweet 9
  • Zimbabwean Journalist Faith Zaba Released on Bail After Power Outage Delays Hearing

    30 shares
    Share 12 Tweet 8
  • Zimbabwe’s CVR Rocked by Sophisticated Scam: A Warning to All

    63 shares
    Share 25 Tweet 16
  • Family Feud Turns Deadly: Grandson Accused of Killing 89-Year-Old Grandmother

    86 shares
    Share 34 Tweet 22
  • The 3-Minute Marriage: A Tale of Love, Laughter, and Annulment

    52 shares
    Share 21 Tweet 13

Popular This Week

  • Roosevelt Girls High School in Hot Water: Parents Raise Concerns Over Fees and Governance

    Roosevelt Girls High School in Hot Water: Parents Raise Concerns Over Fees and Governance

    384 shares
    Share 154 Tweet 96
  • Themba Gorimbo: The MMA Fighter Walking a Tightrope Between Sports and Politics

    190 shares
    Share 76 Tweet 48
  • $4 Million Ecobank Heist: Security Guard Arrested in Major Breakthrough

    182 shares
    Share 73 Tweet 46
  • 50 Cent’s Ex Exposes Him as a Cheapskate

    118 shares
    Share 47 Tweet 30
  • Family Feud Turns Deadly: Grandson Accused of Killing 89-Year-Old Grandmother

    86 shares
    Share 34 Tweet 22
  • Teacher Takes Own Life at Kwite Primary School

    85 shares
    Share 34 Tweet 21
  • Police Crack Down on Illicit Liquor Factory

    82 shares
    Share 33 Tweet 21
  • Significant Dagga Shipment Intercepted in Harare

    74 shares
    Share 30 Tweet 19
  • Police Officer Drags Ex-Wife to Court Over Maintenance

    70 shares
    Share 28 Tweet 18
  • South African President Condemns Xenophobic Movement

    65 shares
    Share 26 Tweet 16

Popular This Month

  • Susan Mutami’s Desperate Plea To  Temba  Mliswa

    Susan Mutami’s Desperate Plea To Temba Mliswa

    457 shares
    Share 183 Tweet 114
  • Roosevelt Girls High School in Hot Water: Parents Raise Concerns Over Fees and Governance

    384 shares
    Share 154 Tweet 96
  • Courtroom Exchange: Mai Jeremiah Questioned by Defense Lawyer

    352 shares
    Share 141 Tweet 88
  • Street Preacher’s Double Life Exposed

    300 shares
    Share 120 Tweet 75
  • Former President Robert Mugabe’s Son , Chatunga Causes Havoc in Mazowe

    273 shares
    Share 109 Tweet 68
  • 77-Year Marriage Ends Over 60-Year-Old Secret

    272 shares
    Share 109 Tweet 68
  • The Whipping Girls of Limpopo

    261 shares
    Share 104 Tweet 65
  • Man Narrowly Escapes Becoming a Lion Snack

    261 shares
    Share 104 Tweet 65
  • The Pilot Who Flew Under the Radar for 20 Years

    243 shares
    Share 97 Tweet 61
  • “Sekuru Malawi” Scams in Mbare

    235 shares
    Share 94 Tweet 59

Most Read Stories

  • “Zimbabwe Is Discrediting SADC”

    ZANU PF Accused Of Bribing SADC Elders To Retain From Losing Power

    5250 shares
    Share 2100 Tweet 1313
  • Madzibaba gets Toyota Aqua after explaining new currency ZiG to church

    4543 shares
    Share 1817 Tweet 1136
  • Breaking News: Zimbabwe launches New Currency (Zig)

    4283 shares
    Share 1713 Tweet 1071
  • Guide : How to access 2023 Zimsec Ordinary O Level results online

    3977 shares
    Share 1591 Tweet 994
  • Uganda Police Officer Shoots Wife Dead After Mocking Him Over Man-U Loss

    3905 shares
    Share 1562 Tweet 976
  • Floods hit Gweru

    3596 shares
    Share 1438 Tweet 899
  • Mashura pa Gokwe musi wa 12.02.24

    3548 shares
    Share 1419 Tweet 887
  • Secret message for ED after his inauguration

    3487 shares
    Share 1395 Tweet 872
  • Heatwave Warning:Expect Extremely hot temp ranging from 36° to 41° until 12 March

    3396 shares
    Share 1358 Tweet 849
  • Here is the reckless Kombi Driver!!!!!!!!!!! See pics here

    3223 shares
    Share 1289 Tweet 806

  • About Us
  • Contact Us
  • FAQ
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms of Service
  • Home

Welcome Back!

Login to your account below

Forgotten Password?

Retrieve your password

Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

Log In
No Result
View All Result
  • News that Matters
    • News
    • Health and Diseases
    • Technology
    • Religion
    • Horror and Disaster
    • Elections 2023
  • Crime and Courts
  • Celebrity
  • Sports
  • Mjolo
  • Breaking News