Saturday, June 7, 2025
No Result
View All Result
News Report  Zimbabwe
  • News that Matters
    • News
    • Health and Diseases
    • Technology
    • Religion
    • Horror and Disaster
    • Elections 2023
  • Crime and Courts
  • Celebrity
  • Sports
  • Mjolo
  • Breaking News
  • News that Matters
    • News
    • Health and Diseases
    • Technology
    • Religion
    • Horror and Disaster
    • Elections 2023
  • Crime and Courts
  • Celebrity
  • Sports
  • Mjolo
  • Breaking News
No Result
View All Result
News Report  Zimbabwe
No Result
View All Result
Home News

Court clears man who was found with stolen car

September 26, 2023
0
Zhao Jiaotong  And His Alleged Two Accomplices Were Denied Bail

A man who was convicted and sentenced to seven years imprisonment for car theft, had his sentence overturned after it was found that police had no evidence linking him to the crime and they gave contradicting statements during trial.

Madimetsa Marema successfully appealed his conviction in the North Gauteng High Court in Pretoria.

Marema was arrested at his house in Olievenhoutbosch in November 2017 after a red Lexus that was reported stolen a week earlier, was found parked next to his house.

According to Marema, his friend, identified as Lusana, came to his home one evening driving a red Lexus. There was a baby seat in the car and Lusana removed it and left it at Marema’s house.
Marema said Lusana then left the car with him as there was no parking space at his house. He said this was not odd, as Lusana drove different cars. He also didn’t find it weird for Lusana to remove the baby seat as he had children.

The next day, police came to his house and told him that the car was reported stolen, he told police that the car was not his, but belonged to his friend.

During trial, the arresting officers gave conflicting statements, however, the Regional Court concluded that the very feature of dissonance in their versions indicates that they had not rehearsed their testimony or colluded a narrative against Marema.

In his appeal, Marema submitted that the trial court erred in accepting the versions of the police officers in the face of a multitude of contradictions.

Furthermore, he added that the court erred in ignoring the fact that he took the officers to Lusana’s home and they failed to attach any weight to this fact.

After hearing the appeal, Judge David Makhoba and Acting Judge Irene de Vos said the court must be convinced that Marema is guilty beyond a reasonable doubt.

The judges said the court cannot reject Marema’s version solely on the basis that it was improbable, but only once the trial court has found, on credible evidence, that the explanation is false.

During trial, the Regional Court said common sense dictates that if one sees a friend in a motor vehicle for the first time, one would be expected to make enquiries about the car before keeping it at their place.

In the appeal, it was said that it was true that Marema’s version presents him as suspicious, lacking in common sense, possibly overly complacent, inactive, incurious and strange.

However, it was held that Marema’s failure to ask questions only renders his behaviour suspicious, and a suspicious explanation is not the equivalent of a false explanation, and his explanation cannot be rejected for being suspicious – only if it is found to be false.

It was also heard how the arresting officers contradicted each other and also on material issues, contradicted themselves.

“There are many more contradictions between the evidence of the two officers … whether Marema provided the officers with Lusana’s number, whether Marema called Lusana … The trial court failed to deal with these contradictions,” said the judges.

It was further added that the contradictions were so many that they cast doubt on the reliability of the evidence.

The court said the contradictions are material and it can’t be concluded that they are immaterial as these contradictions cast doubt on whether the State managed to build a strong case against Marema.

Based on the evidence, the judges said they are not persuaded that Marema was guilty beyond reasonable doubt.

“The basis for this belief is that Marema’s version, although suspicious, is reasonably possibly true. In addition, the evidence of the officers gave against it was so contradictory that the court could not rely on their evidence,” said the judges.

Source IOL

Tags: courtMaremaStolen car

Related Posts

Two Zimbabwean Care Home Workers in the UK attacked, one killed

Two Zimbabwean Care Home Workers in the UK attacked, one killed

by Nyathi
June 7, 2025
0

A devastating attack on two Zimbabwean care home workers has left the community in shock and grief. Charity Kaseke, 24,...

Bulawayo Prison Horror-20 Years for Gang Assault

Stranded in Zimbabwe- The Plight of South African Nationals

by Nyathi
June 7, 2025
0

In the sweltering cells of Harare Remand Prison, a group of South African nationals are languishing, their lives put on...

Masvingo Council Official Takes His Own Life

Masvingo Council Official Takes His Own Life

by Nyathi
June 6, 2025
0

A shocking incident has rocked the Masvingo community after Pius Nyatsanza, the Planning and Economic Affairs Executive Officer for Masvingo...

Nephew Butchers  Uncle Over  Goat

Nephew Butchers Uncle Over Goat

by Nyathi
June 6, 2025
0

A chilling incident has shaken the village of Chinyama in Muzarabani, leaving a trail of death and destruction in its...

Truck Driver Loses Life in Brutal Robbery Attack

Truck Driver Loses Life in Brutal Robbery Attack

by Nyathi
June 5, 2025
0

A tragic incident has shaken the transport industry after a truck driver succumbed to severe injuries sustained in a violent...

Hyena Attack Leaves Man Fighting for Life

Hyena Attack Leaves Man Fighting for Life

by Nyathi
June 5, 2025
0

A terrifying encounter between a man and a hyena has left the community in shock. Wiseman Ngozo, a resident of...

Please login to join discussion

Trending News Today

  • Two Zimbabwean Care Home Workers in the UK attacked, one killed

    Two Zimbabwean Care Home Workers in the UK attacked, one killed

    99 shares
    Share 40 Tweet 25
  • ZEP Holders Breathe a Sigh of Relief as SCA Rules in Their Favor

    94 shares
    Share 38 Tweet 24
  • Widow Caught in Bed With Lover a Week After Burying Husband

    174 shares
    Share 70 Tweet 44
  • Its Open Season for Witch Hunters ‘Tsikamutandas’ – TMPC, Police Join Forces

    42 shares
    Share 17 Tweet 11
  • Sangoma Turns to Lion Snack

    138 shares
    Share 55 Tweet 35
  • Fake Doctor leaves 23-year-old hypnotized

    40 shares
    Share 16 Tweet 10
  • Chiredzi: CIO Officer Goes Rogue

    89 shares
    Share 36 Tweet 22
  • Teenager Convicted for Falsely Accusing a Man of Rape

    36 shares
    Share 14 Tweet 9
  • Masvingo Council Official Takes His Own Life

    67 shares
    Share 27 Tweet 17
  • Dead Man Walking , Literally .

    31 shares
    Share 12 Tweet 8

Popular This Week

  • Fatal Dog Attack Exposes Mike Mupinga’s Troubling Past

    Fatal Dog Attack Exposes Mike Mupinga’s Troubling Past

    274 shares
    Share 110 Tweet 69
  • Widow Caught in Bed With Lover a Week After Burying Husband

    174 shares
    Share 70 Tweet 44
  • The Turbulent Life of President Mnangagwa: A Story of Helicopters, Close Calls, and Air Force Angst

    142 shares
    Share 57 Tweet 36
  • Pastor’s Pulpit Shame- Church Leader Caught in Love Triangle

    140 shares
    Share 56 Tweet 35
  • Sangoma Turns to Lion Snack

    138 shares
    Share 55 Tweet 35
  • Serial South African Killer Escapes To Zimbabwe

    111 shares
    Share 44 Tweet 28
  • COVID-19 Variant Alert: WHO Urges Global Vigilance

    110 shares
    Share 44 Tweet 28
  • The Fake Doc- “Take Lacto And Fruits Three Times a Day”

    109 shares
    Share 44 Tweet 27
  • Two Zimbabwean Care Home Workers in the UK attacked, one killed

    99 shares
    Share 40 Tweet 25
  • Daughter and Son-in-Law Swindle Father Out of $100k

    161 shares
    Share 64 Tweet 40

Popular This Month

  • How to Legally Avoid Paying the US$92 ZBC Radio Licence Fee in Zimbabwe

    How to Legally Avoid Paying the US$92 ZBC Radio Licence Fee in Zimbabwe

    600 shares
    Share 240 Tweet 150
  • Bulawayo Police Bust Vuzu Party, Arrest 13 Youths

    324 shares
    Share 130 Tweet 81
  • Unhealed Wounds-Remembering the 21 Mothers of Emkhonyeni Who Were Burnt Alive

    314 shares
    Share 126 Tweet 79
  • Apostle Eunor Guti Declines Wicknell Chivayo’s Lavish Gift

    274 shares
    Share 110 Tweet 69
  • Fatal Dog Attack Exposes Mike Mupinga’s Troubling Past

    274 shares
    Share 110 Tweet 69
  • Loophole or Legal Gymnastics? Zimbabwean Schools Find Ways Around Fee Payment Rule

    248 shares
    Share 99 Tweet 62
  • New ‘ lobola’ Fees for Foreigners Seeking Medical Care in Gauteng

    240 shares
    Share 96 Tweet 60
  • The Despicable Scam at Zimbabwe’s Hospitals; Its Business Nothing Personal.

    240 shares
    Share 96 Tweet 60
  • Philanthropy or Publicity Stunt? Wicknell Chivayo’s Lavish Gift to Jah Prayzah’s Team

    212 shares
    Share 85 Tweet 53
  • Hospital Investigates Disappearance of Infant’s Body

    205 shares
    Share 82 Tweet 51

Most Read Stories

  • “Zimbabwe Is Discrediting SADC”

    ZANU PF Accused Of Bribing SADC Elders To Retain From Losing Power

    5239 shares
    Share 2096 Tweet 1310
  • Madzibaba gets Toyota Aqua after explaining new currency ZiG to church

    4533 shares
    Share 1813 Tweet 1133
  • Breaking News: Zimbabwe launches New Currency (Zig)

    4279 shares
    Share 1712 Tweet 1070
  • Guide : How to access 2023 Zimsec Ordinary O Level results online

    3973 shares
    Share 1589 Tweet 993
  • Uganda Police Officer Shoots Wife Dead After Mocking Him Over Man-U Loss

    3893 shares
    Share 1557 Tweet 973
  • Floods hit Gweru

    3593 shares
    Share 1437 Tweet 898
  • Mashura pa Gokwe musi wa 12.02.24

    3544 shares
    Share 1418 Tweet 886
  • Secret message for ED after his inauguration

    3481 shares
    Share 1392 Tweet 870
  • Heatwave Warning:Expect Extremely hot temp ranging from 36° to 41° until 12 March

    3394 shares
    Share 1358 Tweet 849
  • Here is the reckless Kombi Driver!!!!!!!!!!! See pics here

    3218 shares
    Share 1287 Tweet 805

  • About Us
  • Contact Us
  • FAQ
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms of Service
  • Home

Welcome Back!

Login to your account below

Forgotten Password?

Retrieve your password

Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

Log In
No Result
View All Result
  • News that Matters
    • News
    • Health and Diseases
    • Technology
    • Religion
    • Horror and Disaster
    • Elections 2023
  • Crime and Courts
  • Celebrity
  • Sports
  • Mjolo
  • Breaking News