Saturday, June 28, 2025
No Result
View All Result
News Report  Zimbabwe
  • News that Matters
    • News
    • Health and Diseases
    • Technology
    • Religion
    • Horror and Disaster
    • Elections 2023
  • Crime and Courts
  • Celebrity
  • Sports
  • Mjolo
  • Breaking News
  • News that Matters
    • News
    • Health and Diseases
    • Technology
    • Religion
    • Horror and Disaster
    • Elections 2023
  • Crime and Courts
  • Celebrity
  • Sports
  • Mjolo
  • Breaking News
No Result
View All Result
News Report  Zimbabwe
No Result
View All Result
Home News

“We have reached . . . stalemate,’Ukraine has lost the war-Valery Zaluzhny

November 8, 2023
0
“We have reached . . . stalemate,’Ukraine has lost the war-Valery Zaluzhny

Ukraine has lost the war. That is not fake news from social media. It is not propaganda from Russian media. It is what follows deductively from statements made by the commander-in-chief of the Ukrainian armed forces, General Valery Zaluzhny, in a November 1 interview with The Economist.

In that interview, Zaluzhny assesses that “we have reached . . . stalemate.” As for Ukraine’s chances of emerging from that stalemate victorious, his prognosis is that “There will most likely be no deep and beautiful breakthrough.”

An admission of a stalemate is not an admission of defeat. But a stalemate entails a long war of attrition. And in a long war, according to The Economist, Zaluzhny “acknowledges [that] Russia has the advantage.” “There is no question in General Zaluzhny’s mind,” The Economist reports, “that a long war favors Russia.” Zaluzhny says that “The biggest risk of an attritional trench war is that it can drag on for years and wear down the Ukrainian state . . .. sooner or later we are going to find that we simply don’t have enough people to fight.”

A close aide to Ukrainian president Volodymyr Zelensky told Time magazine, in an interview published the same day, that even if the United States gave Ukraine all the weapons it needed, they “don’t have the men to use them.”

From those statements it follows that Ukraine has lost the war. The war has reached a stalemate. A stalemate entails a long war of attrition. A long war of attrition favors Russia because Ukraine will run out of men.

In a long essay published simultaneously by The Economist, Zaluzhny explains in more detail that a long entrenched war favors Russia: “the war at the present stage is gradually moving to a positional form, a way out of which in the historical retrospect has always been difficult for both the Armed Forces and the state as a whole.

At the same time, the prolongation of a war, as a rule, in most cases, is beneficial to one of the parties to the conflict. In our particular case, it is the Russian federation, as it gives it the opportunity to reconstitute and build up its military power.”

Zaluzhny goes on go explain that a war of attrition “leads to the lack of Ukraine’s ability to achieve superiority over the enemy in reserves by increasing their number” because “[c]ompared to Ukraine, the Russian federation has almost three times more mobilization human resources.”

And it is not only in the number of troops that Russia benefits from a superiority that will wear Ukraine down. US led sanctions were intended to exhaust the Russian economy until it was incapable of funding its war. But, in his essay, Zaluzhny writes that “Russia at this time retains and is able to maintain a superiority in weapons and equipment, missiles and ammunition for a considerable time, while the capabilities of the military industry are increasing, despite the introduction by the world’s leading countries of unprecedented sanctions against the aggressor state.”

Russia has a numerical advantage in equipment and ammunition and its production is increasing. Whereas, “[t]he Armed Forces of Ukraine are provided with extensive materiel and logistical assistance by Partner Nations, however, given the increased intensity of average daily missiles and ammunition consumption, it is not possible to accumulate these funds in the required volumes.”

Russia has won the war because it has settled into a stalemate, a long war of attrition in which, over time, Russian numerical superiority in men and weapons will outlast Ukraine and wear them down.

But it is important to analyze, not only the assessment that Zaluzhny published, but also the question of why he chose to publish on so public a Western pulpit.

In the Time article published on the same day, some of Zelensky’s “closest aides” say that the president is in conflict with his generals and that, “hardened” into a position that no longer reflects the reality on the battlefield, he is not listening to them. Zelensky’s long expired belief “in Ukraine’s ultimate victory over Russia . . . worries some of his advisors” because it “verg[es] on the messianic” and hinders their ability to be flexible and adapt their strategy to the evolving reality. Zelensky “deludes himself.” His close aide complained that “We’re out of options. We’re not winning. But try telling him that.”

Zelensky is not listening to his generals, and that is hurting the armed forces and the people of Ukraine. Perhaps since Zelensky won’t listen to his top general, his top general talked to Zelensky’s Western backers. Perhaps if Zelensky won’t listen to Zaluzhny, he’ll listen to Washington who listened to Zaluzhny. Zaluzhny’s word carries weight. He is a very respected general: even by Russia.

In neither his interview with The Economist nor his accompanying essay, does Zaluzhny ever mention Zelensky. He is talking past the president, not to him.

Zaluzhny’s message to Time’s audience in the political West may also be intended as a way of getting the message through to Zelensky. The full message is devastating. The headlines focus on the word “stalemate.” But, as Kremlin spokesman Dmitry Peskov responded to Zaluzhny’s assessment, “No, it has not reached a stalemate.”

The diagnosis of stalemate relies on a misunderstanding of the different strategic approaches to the war by the two armies. The Economist illustrates the stalemate by saying that “Five months into its counter-offensive, Ukraine has managed to advance by just 17 kilometers. Russia fought for ten months around Bakhmut in the east “to take a town six by six kilometers”.

But that measures the results by territory taken. That is Ukraine’s goal because they are trying to recapture land that Russia has taken and push Russia back out of its borders. But Russia is not fighting for territory but for victory over the Ukrainian armed forces.

Victory for Russia, for now, is measured, not in territory, but in the attrition of Ukrainian men, equipment and artillery. By this metric, the war is not a stalemate. Russia has acquired little land, but they are attaining their goal. Since Ukraine began its counteroffensive, the loss of advanced equipment, including jet fighters and NATO supplied tanks, has been staggering, and the loss of lives horrifying. Ukraine is running out of weapons and, as Zaluzhny and Zelensky’s aides have said, they are running out of men even faster.

But Russia is also winning land. The attrition of the Ukrainian forces has created a vulnerability that Russia now seems to be exploiting to launch their own version of a counteroffensive. They are methodically advancing on a number of strategic fronts. The most important may be Avdiivka, the defeat of which could open the door to the Donbass for Russian forces, allowing Russia to solidify the borders of its newly annexed territories.

Ukraine is desperately redeploying troops from the southern front, suggesting that they are running out of men and lack reserves to send into Avdiivka and that the loss of key strategic land may be imminent.

Zaluzhny opposes Zelensky’s strategy of spending lives on Avdiivka as he opposed his strategy of spending lives on Bakhmut. But Zelensky is not listening. That may be why Zaluzhny took his message to Zelensky’s patrons. The attritional war now focused on Avdiivka could lead to the running out of men and the loss of pivotal land that could signal the beginning of the realization that Ukraine has lost the war.

Source Zbcnews

Tags: ukraineValery Zaluzhny

Related Posts

The Rangemore Robbers’ Wild Ride Ends in Court

The Rangemore Robbers’ Wild Ride Ends in Court

by Nyathi
June 27, 2025
0

In a shocking turn of events, the notorious Makumbi brothers, Enock and Roy, were sentenced to 35 years each in...

Albinism Awareness Campaign Rocks Masvingo

Albinism Awareness Campaign Rocks Masvingo

by Nyathi
June 27, 2025
0

The Albino Charity Organization of Zimbabwe, led by Founder and Executive Director Ms. Loveness Mainato, joined forces with M Hugo...

Former President Robert Mugabe’s Son , Chatunga  Causes  Havoc in Mazowe

Former President Robert Mugabe’s Son , Chatunga Causes Havoc in Mazowe

by Nyathi
June 27, 2025
0

A security guard at an Ultimate Mining concession in Mazowe is battling for his life after being brutally assaulted by,...

Thokozani Khupe ‘s  Cry

Thokozani Khupe ‘s Cry

by Nyathi
June 27, 2025
0

Opposition legislator Thokozani Khupe has thrown down the gauntlet, demanding answers on the sugar tax funds meant for cancer treatment....

Zanu PF’s Manicaland Meltdown: A Tale of Two Chairwomen

Zanu PF’s Manicaland Meltdown: A Tale of Two Chairwomen

by Nyathi
June 27, 2025
0

In a shocking display of party infighting, the Manicaland women's league of Zanu PF recently played host to a heated...

Minister Moyo’s Nuclear Option: NSSA Board Sacked in Power Play

Minister Moyo’s Nuclear Option: NSSA Board Sacked in Power Play

by Nyathi
June 25, 2025
0

In a shocking move, Minister Edgar Moyo has fired the entire board of directors at the National Social Security Authority...

Please login to join discussion

Trending News Today

  • Former President Robert Mugabe’s Son , Chatunga  Causes  Havoc in Mazowe

    Former President Robert Mugabe’s Son , Chatunga Causes Havoc in Mazowe

    137 shares
    Share 55 Tweet 34
  • The Rangemore Robbers’ Wild Ride Ends in Court

    88 shares
    Share 35 Tweet 22
  • AFM Pastor’s US$158K Fiasco: A Holy Heist?

    80 shares
    Share 32 Tweet 20
  • Albinism Awareness Campaign Rocks Masvingo

    44 shares
    Share 18 Tweet 11
  • Zanu PF’s Manicaland Meltdown: A Tale of Two Chairwomen

    34 shares
    Share 14 Tweet 9
  • Thokozani Khupe ‘s Cry

    27 shares
    Share 11 Tweet 7
  • Kindman Ndlovu Quits

    22 shares
    Share 9 Tweet 6
  • 77-Year Marriage Ends Over 60-Year-Old Secret

    237 shares
    Share 95 Tweet 59
  • Minister Moyo’s Nuclear Option: NSSA Board Sacked in Power Play

    57 shares
    Share 23 Tweet 14
  • Mai Titi’s Mysterious Message

    83 shares
    Share 33 Tweet 21

Popular This Week

  • Courtroom Exchange: Mai Jeremiah Questioned by Defense Lawyer

    Courtroom Exchange: Mai Jeremiah Questioned by Defense Lawyer

    328 shares
    Share 131 Tweet 82
  • 77-Year Marriage Ends Over 60-Year-Old Secret

    237 shares
    Share 95 Tweet 59
  • Fire Destroys XGX Mall in Harare CBD

    142 shares
    Share 57 Tweet 36
  • Former President Robert Mugabe’s Son , Chatunga Causes Havoc in Mazowe

    137 shares
    Share 55 Tweet 34
  • Pastor Dumi’s Holy Debt Drama

    123 shares
    Share 49 Tweet 31
  • Polyandrous Pandemonium: Woman Drags Husband to Court Over Lack of Financial Support

    118 shares
    Share 47 Tweet 30
  • The Rangemore Robbers’ Wild Ride Ends in Court

    88 shares
    Share 35 Tweet 22
  • ZRP Investigates “Vuzu” Party, Cracks Down on Car Thief

    87 shares
    Share 35 Tweet 22
  • Armed Robbers Hijack Mercedes Benz in Bulawayo

    83 shares
    Share 33 Tweet 21
  • Mai Titi’s Mysterious Message

    83 shares
    Share 33 Tweet 21

Popular This Month

  • Susan Mutami’s Desperate Plea To  Temba  Mliswa

    Susan Mutami’s Desperate Plea To Temba Mliswa

    438 shares
    Share 175 Tweet 110
  • Courtroom Exchange: Mai Jeremiah Questioned by Defense Lawyer

    328 shares
    Share 131 Tweet 82
  • Fatal Dog Attack Exposes Mike Mupinga’s Troubling Past

    295 shares
    Share 118 Tweet 74
  • Street Preacher’s Double Life Exposed

    289 shares
    Share 116 Tweet 72
  • Widow Caught in Bed With Lover a Week After Burying Husband

    270 shares
    Share 108 Tweet 68
  • Man Narrowly Escapes Becoming a Lion Snack

    253 shares
    Share 101 Tweet 63
  • The Whipping Girls of Limpopo

    251 shares
    Share 100 Tweet 63
  • 77-Year Marriage Ends Over 60-Year-Old Secret

    237 shares
    Share 95 Tweet 59
  • The Pilot Who Flew Under the Radar for 20 Years

    236 shares
    Share 94 Tweet 59
  • “Sekuru Malawi” Scams in Mbare

    220 shares
    Share 88 Tweet 55

Most Read Stories

  • “Zimbabwe Is Discrediting SADC”

    ZANU PF Accused Of Bribing SADC Elders To Retain From Losing Power

    5248 shares
    Share 2099 Tweet 1312
  • Madzibaba gets Toyota Aqua after explaining new currency ZiG to church

    4541 shares
    Share 1816 Tweet 1135
  • Breaking News: Zimbabwe launches New Currency (Zig)

    4281 shares
    Share 1712 Tweet 1070
  • Guide : How to access 2023 Zimsec Ordinary O Level results online

    3977 shares
    Share 1591 Tweet 994
  • Uganda Police Officer Shoots Wife Dead After Mocking Him Over Man-U Loss

    3900 shares
    Share 1560 Tweet 975
  • Floods hit Gweru

    3595 shares
    Share 1438 Tweet 899
  • Mashura pa Gokwe musi wa 12.02.24

    3546 shares
    Share 1418 Tweet 887
  • Secret message for ED after his inauguration

    3485 shares
    Share 1394 Tweet 871
  • Heatwave Warning:Expect Extremely hot temp ranging from 36° to 41° until 12 March

    3395 shares
    Share 1358 Tweet 849
  • Here is the reckless Kombi Driver!!!!!!!!!!! See pics here

    3222 shares
    Share 1289 Tweet 806

  • About Us
  • Contact Us
  • FAQ
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms of Service
  • Home

Welcome Back!

Login to your account below

Forgotten Password?

Retrieve your password

Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

Log In
No Result
View All Result
  • News that Matters
    • News
    • Health and Diseases
    • Technology
    • Religion
    • Horror and Disaster
    • Elections 2023
  • Crime and Courts
  • Celebrity
  • Sports
  • Mjolo
  • Breaking News