Wednesday, July 2, 2025
No Result
View All Result
News Report  Zimbabwe
  • News that Matters
    • News
    • Health and Diseases
    • Technology
    • Religion
    • Horror and Disaster
    • Elections 2023
  • Crime and Courts
  • Celebrity
  • Sports
  • Mjolo
  • Breaking News
  • News that Matters
    • News
    • Health and Diseases
    • Technology
    • Religion
    • Horror and Disaster
    • Elections 2023
  • Crime and Courts
  • Celebrity
  • Sports
  • Mjolo
  • Breaking News
No Result
View All Result
News Report  Zimbabwe
No Result
View All Result
Home Crime and Courts

Motsoaledi challenges ZEP decision

September 19, 2023
0
Motsoaledi challenges ZEP decision

Home Affairs Minister Aaron Motsoaledi says the Gauteng High Court in Pretoria had no right to “interfere” with the government’s decision to terminate 14-year-old Zimbabwe Exemption Permits (ZEPs). However, through his advocate, William Mokhare, he added that he was open to extending the 31 December deadline for the special permits, which granted legal status to around 178 000 Zimbabweans living in South Africa.

Motsoaledi is applying for leave to appeal the High Court’s 28 June ruling that found the minister’s decision to end the ZEPs “unlawful, unconstitutional, and invalid”. The court extended the permits for 12 months from 28 June, pending the conclusion of a “fair process” that includes an adequate public participation process the court found had not been done before the 7 June gazette for the ZEP termination.

The June judgment followed the Helen Suzman Foundation’s application to set aside Motsoaledi’s announcement to discontinue the special permits, which began in 2009. During a virtual hearing on Monday, Mokhare told the High Court that Motsoaledi agreed that the ZEP issue was “not only a matter of great importance and considerable public significance, but…a matter that raises huge constitutional implications”.

Mokhare said its importance entailed the government’s prerogative to deal “with the acceptance of foreigners within its own borders” – factors, Mokhare contended, that included “asylum, immigration, refugee, economic, political, and socioeconomic considerations”.

He recalled that the reasons for the special dispensation was political and economic “instability” in Zimbabwe, which caused “strain” on South Africa due to “the influx” of citizens in the country’s northern neighbour.

“The only way the minister’s decision could be attacked is whether the minister’s decision is rational. Rationality is a low-threshold type of review because it is more linked to the principle of deference, where the courts are loathed to interfere with executive decision-making, particularly where it is more linked to policy,” Mokhare said, adding that policy was not a “specialised terrain” of the courts.

Mokhare argued:

If the court finds that the initial decision, which was to give reprieve on a temporary basis for Zimbabweans because of the situation in their country, then the court cannot interfere with the decision to terminate if the executive [the government] concludes that those conditions are no longer prevalent. And therefore, this dispensation must come to an end.
But Mokhare said Motsoaledi was not opposed to extending the deadline.

“Nothing prevents the minister from always looking at the conditions prevalent at the time and [taking] a decision that does not adversely affect the ZEP members.”

However, the Helen Suzman Foundation – through its advocate, Carol Steinberg – asserted that Motsoaledi’s application should be dismissed. Steinberg said the minister should be given a “punitive costs order” because his appeal had “no prospects of success” at the Supreme Court of Appeal.

“A mere possibility of success, an arguable case, or one that is not hopeless is not enough. In short, our argument is that there are actually zero prospects of success in this case,” Steinberg asserted.

She added that the 178 000 people affected by Motsoaledi’s decision to terminate the permits had an “iron-clad right” to be heard before regulations were put in place.

“In law, there is a watertight obligation to hear what affected people have to say before a decision impacting on their lives is made. It is the first principle of natural justice. It is [not in doubt] that the minister did not, in fact, hear from the affected people before making the [termination] decision. He called for representations later,” Steinberg said.

She added:

There is no court in South Africa that will ever say that the minister is entitled to make a decision – which profoundly impacts on the lives of many, many people – without hearing from them first. Her views were supported by advocate David Simonsz, who represented the Consortium for Refugees and Migrants in South Africa. Simonsz said no one – including the High Court – wanted to interfere with the government’s work.

He added that the Department of Home Affairs had to use the court-ordered 12-month extension to do a proper public participation process.

“What the minister should do is take the opportunity afforded to him by this court to follow a lawful process and make whatever decision he chooses to make – once he takes into account the just and proper submissions and representations of those affected. That is the proper way forward,” Simonsz argued.

But Mokhare dismissed the argument that there was no public consultation, saying the law allowed participation whether before or after a decision is taken and that the government had solicited views and opened visa applications for existing ZEP holders, who would not be affected by the December deadline should it arrive without their applications being finalised.

“The point here is that we say there was [consultation] – there was [consultation] adapted to the circumstances of the case. We submit that there are prospects of success on the merits.”

The High Court reserved judgment.

Source NewZimbabwe

Tags: Aaron MotsoaledicourtZEP

Related Posts

Fake Receipt Fiasco: Two Men Busted for Ridiculous Scam

Fake Receipt Fiasco: Two Men Busted for Ridiculous Scam

by Nyathi
July 1, 2025
0

In a bizarre case of retail robbery, two men, Chamunorwa Paul Anesu and Nakai Hodera, were sentenced to five years...

Wildlife Crime Investigation Underway in Hwange National Park

Wildlife Crime Investigation Underway in Hwange National Park

by Nyathi
June 30, 2025
0

Wildlife authorities have launched a probe into the discovery of a male elephant carcass with a missing tusk in Hwange...

ZRP’s Food Scandal

Justice Served: ZRP Nabs Suspects

by Nyathi
June 30, 2025
0

The Zimbabwe Republic Police (ZRP) has announced the arrest of two suspects in connection with serious crimes committed in the...

Harare Businesswoman on the Run: Warrant of Arrest Issued Over Alleged Fraud

Harare Businesswoman on the Run: Warrant of Arrest Issued Over Alleged Fraud

by Nyathi
June 28, 2025
0

A Harare businesswoman, Lilian Nyamasoka, has been issued with a warrant of arrest after failing to appear in court on...

Mt Darwin “Robbery” Reclassified: Police Confirm Cash and Gold Recovered

Mt Darwin “Robbery” Reclassified: Police Confirm Cash and Gold Recovered

by Nyathi
June 28, 2025
0

A dramatic twist has emerged in the Mt Darwin incident, initially reported as a major armed robbery. The Zimbabwe Republic...

203 Cases of Serious Crimes Suspect in Custody

203 Cases of Serious Crimes Suspect in Custody

by Nyathi
June 28, 2025
0

Tafadzwa Janyure Zivirenyika, a suspect linked to a notorious machete gang, has been arrested in Masvingo for terrorizing villagers in...

Please login to join discussion

Trending News Today

  • Roosevelt Girls High School in Hot Water: Parents Raise Concerns Over Fees and Governance

    Roosevelt Girls High School in Hot Water: Parents Raise Concerns Over Fees and Governance

    320 shares
    Share 128 Tweet 80
  • Themba Gorimbo: The MMA Fighter Walking a Tightrope Between Sports and Politics

    165 shares
    Share 66 Tweet 41
  • Fake Receipt Fiasco: Two Men Busted for Ridiculous Scam

    32 shares
    Share 13 Tweet 8
  • Two Tragic Incidents Involving Trains in Zimbabwe

    28 shares
    Share 11 Tweet 7
  • Harare City Council: A Hot Mess of Inefficiency

    24 shares
    Share 10 Tweet 6
  • South African President Condemns Xenophobic Movement

    59 shares
    Share 24 Tweet 15
  • The Rangemore Robbers’ Wild Ride Ends in Court

    164 shares
    Share 66 Tweet 41
  • 7 dead 3 escape the Mass Shooting

    37 shares
    Share 15 Tweet 9
  • Harare Businesswoman on the Run: Warrant of Arrest Issued Over Alleged Fraud

    93 shares
    Share 37 Tweet 23
  • 203 Cases of Serious Crimes Suspect in Custody

    140 shares
    Share 56 Tweet 35

Popular This Week

  • Roosevelt Girls High School in Hot Water: Parents Raise Concerns Over Fees and Governance

    Roosevelt Girls High School in Hot Water: Parents Raise Concerns Over Fees and Governance

    320 shares
    Share 128 Tweet 80
  • Former President Robert Mugabe’s Son , Chatunga Causes Havoc in Mazowe

    255 shares
    Share 102 Tweet 64
  • Themba Gorimbo: The MMA Fighter Walking a Tightrope Between Sports and Politics

    165 shares
    Share 66 Tweet 41
  • The Rangemore Robbers’ Wild Ride Ends in Court

    164 shares
    Share 66 Tweet 41
  • 203 Cases of Serious Crimes Suspect in Custody

    140 shares
    Share 56 Tweet 35
  • AFM Pastor’s US$158K Fiasco: A Holy Heist?

    104 shares
    Share 42 Tweet 26
  • Harare Businesswoman on the Run: Warrant of Arrest Issued Over Alleged Fraud

    93 shares
    Share 37 Tweet 23
  • 77-Year Marriage Ends Over 60-Year-Old Secret

    264 shares
    Share 106 Tweet 66
  • Albinism Awareness Campaign Rocks Masvingo

    62 shares
    Share 25 Tweet 16
  • Paternity Scandal Rocks Marange Village: “This One Is Not Mine”

    61 shares
    Share 24 Tweet 15

Popular This Month

  • Susan Mutami’s Desperate Plea To  Temba  Mliswa

    Susan Mutami’s Desperate Plea To Temba Mliswa

    451 shares
    Share 180 Tweet 113
  • Courtroom Exchange: Mai Jeremiah Questioned by Defense Lawyer

    346 shares
    Share 138 Tweet 87
  • Roosevelt Girls High School in Hot Water: Parents Raise Concerns Over Fees and Governance

    320 shares
    Share 128 Tweet 80
  • Street Preacher’s Double Life Exposed

    297 shares
    Share 119 Tweet 74
  • Widow Caught in Bed With Lover a Week After Burying Husband

    272 shares
    Share 109 Tweet 68
  • 77-Year Marriage Ends Over 60-Year-Old Secret

    264 shares
    Share 106 Tweet 66
  • Man Narrowly Escapes Becoming a Lion Snack

    258 shares
    Share 103 Tweet 65
  • The Whipping Girls of Limpopo

    257 shares
    Share 103 Tweet 64
  • Former President Robert Mugabe’s Son , Chatunga Causes Havoc in Mazowe

    255 shares
    Share 102 Tweet 64
  • The Pilot Who Flew Under the Radar for 20 Years

    240 shares
    Share 96 Tweet 60

Most Read Stories

  • “Zimbabwe Is Discrediting SADC”

    ZANU PF Accused Of Bribing SADC Elders To Retain From Losing Power

    5249 shares
    Share 2100 Tweet 1312
  • Madzibaba gets Toyota Aqua after explaining new currency ZiG to church

    4542 shares
    Share 1817 Tweet 1136
  • Breaking News: Zimbabwe launches New Currency (Zig)

    4282 shares
    Share 1713 Tweet 1071
  • Guide : How to access 2023 Zimsec Ordinary O Level results online

    3977 shares
    Share 1591 Tweet 994
  • Uganda Police Officer Shoots Wife Dead After Mocking Him Over Man-U Loss

    3904 shares
    Share 1562 Tweet 976
  • Floods hit Gweru

    3595 shares
    Share 1438 Tweet 899
  • Mashura pa Gokwe musi wa 12.02.24

    3547 shares
    Share 1419 Tweet 887
  • Secret message for ED after his inauguration

    3486 shares
    Share 1394 Tweet 872
  • Heatwave Warning:Expect Extremely hot temp ranging from 36° to 41° until 12 March

    3395 shares
    Share 1358 Tweet 849
  • Here is the reckless Kombi Driver!!!!!!!!!!! See pics here

    3222 shares
    Share 1289 Tweet 806

  • About Us
  • Contact Us
  • FAQ
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms of Service
  • Home

Welcome Back!

Login to your account below

Forgotten Password?

Retrieve your password

Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

Log In
No Result
View All Result
  • News that Matters
    • News
    • Health and Diseases
    • Technology
    • Religion
    • Horror and Disaster
    • Elections 2023
  • Crime and Courts
  • Celebrity
  • Sports
  • Mjolo
  • Breaking News